top of page

Hiring a Property Manager vs. Hands-on Landlord: Which is Right for You?

Writer's picture: José R. HernándezJosé R. Hernández

Managing rental properties as a first-time landlord can be both exciting and overwhelming. Owning property is a significant investment, and making the right decision about how to manage that investment is crucial. Should you hire a property manager or tackle the responsibility as a hands-on landlord? Each approach has pros and cons, and making the right choice depends on your financial goals, time availability, and personal preferences.


This guide will help you explore the roles, responsibilities, and benefits of both options, along with practical tips and advice to ensure effective property management, regardless of your decision.



Property Manager vs. Hands-on Landlord

The Role of a Property Manager

A property manager is a professional or company that specializes in overseeing and managing real estate on behalf of owners. For landlords who want a more hands-off experience or lack the expertise or time to manage tenants and maintenance, hiring a property manager can be an attractive option.


What Does a Property Manager Do?

Property managers handle a wide range of responsibilities, including:


Advantages of Hiring a Property Manager

  • Saves Time: Managing tenants, maintenance, and administrative tasks can be time-consuming. Property managers take these tasks off your plate.

  • Professional Expertise: Experienced property managers understand market trends, tenant management, and legal compliance, reducing the risks associated with property ownership.

  • Streamlined Tenant Management: They serve as a buffer between you and your tenants, handling disputes, late payments, and potential evictions.

  • Peace of Mind: With someone else managing day-to-day issues, you can focus on other priorities, whether it’s your career, family, or another investment.


While hiring a property manager can be convenient, it comes at a cost, which we’ll discuss later in the blog.


The Duties of a Hands-on Landlord

For property owners who prefer to stay directly involved in their rentals, being a hands-on landlord could be a rewarding choice. This approach means you are responsible for every aspect of property management, from finding tenants to addressing repair requests.


What Does Hands-on Landlording Entail?

Being a self-managing landlord involves tasks such as:

  • Advertising the rental property and screening potential tenants.

  • Drafting lease agreements and collecting rent.

  • Conducting property inspections and managing repairs.

  • Handling tenant inquiries, complaints, and disputes.

  • Staying informed on landlord-tenant regulations to avoid legal consequences.


Benefits of Being a Hands-on Landlord

  • Cost Savings: You can avoid the fees of hiring a property manager, which typically range between 8% and 12% of monthly rental income.

  • Direct Control: You maintain complete control over tenant selection, property management, and financial management.

  • Building Personal Relationships: Working directly with tenants can create trust and rapport, potentially leading to long-term, cooperative tenant relationships.

  • Learning Opportunity: For first-time landlords, managing your property can offer invaluable hands-on experience that benefits future investments.


However, being a hands-on landlord comes with challenges, such as time commitment and the need for strong conflict-resolution skills.


Factors to Consider When Making the Choice

Whether you choose to hire a property manager or manage your rental property yourself depends on several factors. Carefully evaluating these considerations can help you make an informed decision.


Financial Implications

  • Hiring a property manager involves service fees (typically 8%–12% of monthly rent) and sometimes extra charges for tenant placement or maintenance coordination.

  • Self-managing your property eliminates this expense but doesn’t rule out other costs, such as marketing, screening software, and your personal time.


Time Commitment

  • Property management takes significant time, from responding to maintenance requests to handling late payments.

  • If you work a full-time job, have multiple properties, or simply value your free time, a property manager can handle these tasks for you.


Property Type and Location

  • Large or multi-unit properties often require more attention and may benefit from professional management.

  • If your rental property is located far from where you live, logistics may make hands-on management more challenging and expensive.


Tips for Effective Property Management or Landlord Self-Management

Regardless of your decision, there are ways to enhance your success and minimize stress when managing rental properties. Here are some practical tips for each approach.


For Self-Managing Landlords

  1. Educate Yourself on Laws: Familiarize yourself with landlord-tenant laws in your area to avoid legal pitfalls.

  2. Use Property Management Software: Tools like Buildium or Avail can streamline rent collection, tenant screening, and record-keeping.

  3. Create a Maintenance Plan: Develop a list of reliable contractors and backups for emergencies and routine repairs.

  4. Screen Tenants Carefully: Perform background and credit checks to reduce risks of non-payment or property damage.

  5. Build Communication Skills: Positive relationships with tenants can make property management smoother and minimize conflicts.


For Working with a Property Manager

  1. Choose the Right Manager: Research and interview multiple property managers to find one with experience, good reviews, and transparent pricing.

  2. Set Clear Expectations: Define responsibilities and communication preferences upfront to avoid misunderstandings.

  3. Monitor Performance: Regularly review reports on rental income, property inspections, and tenant relations to ensure your property is being managed effectively.


Making the Right Choice for You

Deciding between hiring a property manager and being a hands-on landlord depends on your circumstances and priorities. Whatever option you choose, success starts with understanding the responsibilities and maximizing the benefits of each approach.


If you’re leaning toward being a hands-on landlord, start small and educate yourself on best practices to minimize stress. If hiring a property manager feels like the better fit, take the time to find someone who aligns with your goals and values.


Are you ready to take your first step as a landlord? Share this post with other first-time property owners and join the conversation in the comments below. We’d love to hear your experience and insights about property management!


Did I miss anything? Please let me know in the comments! Also, please subscribe to our blog to receive a notification when new articles arrive.

At Don Asher Management, we've proudly served the Central Florida community for over 70 years. As a locally-owned company with a strong understanding of the local market, we've cultivated substantial relationships with local and national contractors to provide top-quality services. We're dedicated to meeting your property and HOA management needs with a personalized touch, combining our decades of experience and commitment to detail to provide unmatched service. We're confident in our ability to deliver exceptional services tailored just for you. Choose Don Asher Management - where personalized attention meets professional service.

 
 
 

コメント


IREM.png
top_main_menu_1-e1522425355748.png
narpm-e1522425263242.png
communitylogo.png
realtor_logo-e1522425594271.png
Floridarealtors.png
orlandoregionalrealtor.png

©2019 by Don Asher and Associates, Inc. - 1801 Cook Ave. Orlando, FL  32806 - (407) 425-4561

bottom of page